Before I start, let's put it in record at the amount of "ahaha
somebody might finally let him to act evil on screen more" and "yay his character will be IN SPACE" I am having right now at
the report of Benedict being casted in the Star Trek sequel (as the rumoured
'naughty baddie' Khan). We already know that
Simon Pegg is in the sequel, so there's that awesome factor in my head no matter he really ended up as good or the dark side.
*breathes* ok, now that I got the happy squeeing done, let's get back to reviewing. In the non-spoilery short review, the film is well done in terms of the actor choice, which I don't remember the last time I can see the actor fitting the role like it was written with them in mind. The cinematography and the music are excellent (I have been listening to the soundtrack for months and seeing the tracks sliding into place with the actual scene is an absolute treat). The plot, however, are so trimmed (think pared to the bone) that I was disappointed that many of the moments in the book was taken out or modified. I think the problem with such a large cast (all of them pivotal to the film) and with so much story material to show in a short period of time (unlike the BBC verse which there are 7 episodes for all the important storyline to flesh out). I was left yearning for more when the film ends, which I guess could consider as good sign still.
Now, the spoilery parts, which I pull out the few favourite (and a few possibly not so much) moments of the film.
( Behind the cut. Did I mention it's SPOILERY? )All in all, like I've said to
stripedteacups on twitter, the original story is a big mess of human relationship tangle, it's so easy for the director/writer to make a bad hash of it. I am very glad that was not the case at all. In the constraint that they have that is the time limit allowed in a film, this is done quite well and the plot coherent enough for audience to follow. Even with the minor nagging concern that it could have done slightly more to rounded out this film even better that I am still trying to reconcile in my head.
This post can also be found on my Dreamwidth journal over here. Please feel free to use either site to comment.